Criminal Defence Case Studies
Aggravated Burglary Ballarat
Court: County Court of Victoria Ballarat
Charges: Aggravated burglary Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Criminal damage Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Unlawful assault Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) (uplifted from summary)
225+ Google Reviews
Case Overview
This case study involves a 32-year-old man charged with aggravated burglary, criminal damage, and unlawful assault. Despite aggravated burglary carrying a maximum penalty of 25 years' imprisonment, we secured a two-year Community Corrections Order (CCO) with conviction, avoiding immediate prison.
Case Background
In August 2021, our client attended a Ballarat unit complex with others, seeking a man who had allegedly threatened him.
An initial encounter with a neighbour resulted in a push to the chest (unlawful assault). Later, the group confronted another resident, accusing him of pointing a shotgun at our client. They left but returned, banging on windows and doors, frightening the female occupant.
Our client kicked in the door, entered holding a broom handle, realised the occupant was not the intended target, apologised, dropped the broom, and left.
Our Defence Strategy
As experienced criminal defence lawyers in Melbourne, we:
Entered early guilty pleas to maximise sentencing discount.
Tendered psychological and neuropsychological reports showing severe cognitive impairment (IQ 67), literacy and numeracy deficits, and acquired brain injury.
Highlighted social vulnerability, homelessness, and exposure to family violence at the time.
Presented strong rehabilitation evidence, three years without re-offending, drug abstinence, stable housing, and ongoing employment.
Applied Verdins principles to show imprisonment would be disproportionately harsh given cognitive limitations.
Cited R v Talia to emphasise delay and post-offence rehabilitation.
Outcome
- Two-year Community Corrections Order with supervision and Justice Plan condition
- Conviction and discharge for unlawful assault
The Court accepted that rehabilitation progress, disability, and positive life changes justified a non-custodial sentence despite the seriousness of the charge.
Frequently Asked Questions – Aggravated Burglary in Victoria
What is aggravated burglary?
Entering a building as a trespasser with intent to commit an offence while armed or knowing someone is inside.
What is the penalty?
Up to 25 years’ imprisonment.
Can it be defended?
Yes, possible defences include challenging identity, disputing intent, or whether a weapon was present.
Yes, particularly where the offending is linked to personal vulnerabilities, rehabilitation prospects are strong, and the defence presents a compelling case for community-based sentencing.
DISCLAIMER
This is a real case study from an actual matter in our files. We always change details in our case studies to protect client confidentiality, but the charge and the outcome are exactly as they occurred in court. We publish these case studies to give a genuine insight into the types of results we achieve and the range of sentences that may be imposed. Every case is different, and we can't guarantee the same result in your matter. We choose to share some cases because they are representative of typical results, and others because they stand out for exceptional outcomes.