Criminal Defence Case Studies
Aggravated Exposure of an Emergency Worker, Dangerous Driving & Theft
Court: County Court of Victoria Melbourne
Charges: Dangerous driving causing serious injury Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Recklessly cause injury Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Failing to render assistance after a motor vehicle accident Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Fail to report to police if a person is injured Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic), Learner driver driving without supervising driver Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic)
Charges: Dangerous driving causing serious injury Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Recklessly cause injury Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Failing to render assistance after a motor vehicle accident Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), Fail to report to police if a person is injured Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic), Learner driver driving without supervising driver Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic)
225+ Google Reviews
Case Overview
This case study involves a 27-year-old man, who was represented by our criminal lawyers in Melbourne on serious indictable and summary charges, including aggravated exposure of an emergency worker, dangerous driving during a police pursuit, and theft of a motor vehicle.
Following a contested committal, our legal team successfully negotiated a change from intent-based charges to recklessness offences. The County Court imposed a total effective sentence of 3 years and 6 months' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2 years and 4 months.
Case Background
In January 2024, our client and a co-offender broke into a Toyota pre-delivery yard, stole multiple vehicles, and became involved in a high-speed police pursuit through Melbourne's western suburbs.
During the chase, he reached speeds of up to 137 km/h, ran red lights, overtook dangerously, and drove on the wrong side of the road. When police boxed in the stolen vehicle, he collided with both police and civilian cars in attempts to escape.
Police located counterfeit plates, a machete, and stolen identification documents inside the vehicle. A blood test confirmed methylamphetamine in his system.
Our client sustained injuries during his arrest and received hospital treatment before being remanded in custody.
Our Defence Approach
Emma Turnbull Lawyers:
Contested committal proceedings, resulting in intent charges being withdrawn and replaced with recklessness offences
Obtained psychological and neuropsychological assessments diagnosing ADHD, PTSD, stimulant use disorder, and significant childhood trauma affecting decision-making
Argued impaired mental functioning under the Verdins principles and extra-curial punishment for injuries sustained during arrest
Presented rehabilitation evidence from custody, including completion of anger management and drug treatment programs
The Outcome
- Total effective sentence: 3 years and 6 months' imprisonment
- Non-parole period: 2 years and 4 months
- Licence cancellations: Multiple orders running concurrently, with a maximum of 3 years disqualification
- Property forfeiture: Machete and seized stolen property forfeited
The sentencing judge noted that if convicted after trial, the likely sentence would have been 4 years and 6 months with a 3-year non-parole period.
Why This Case Matters
Police pursuit and aggravated exposure offences carry very heavy penalties, including lengthy prison terms and mandatory licence disqualifications. This case shows how strategic litigation at the committal stage, charge negotiations, and strong mitigation evidence can reduce both the seriousness of charges and the overall prison term.
Frequently Asked Questions – Dangerous Driving Causing Serious Injury in Victoria
What is dangerous driving while pursued by police?
Driving in a manner that seriously endangers public safety while knowingly being pursued by police.
What are the penalties?
Significant prison sentences, large fines, and mandatory licence disqualification.
Can these charges be defended?
Yes, potential defences include mistaken identity, disputing the alleged driving behaviour, or necessity in rare situations.
Do I need a lawyer if I'm pleading guilty?
Yes, a criminal lawyer in Melbourne can help secure the lowest possible penalty and ensure your rights are protected.
Will my licence be cancelled?
Yes, mandatory cancellation applies, but the period can sometimes be reduced through legal submissions.
DISCLAIMER
This is a real case study from an actual matter in our files. We always change details in our case studies to protect client confidentiality, but the charge and the outcome are exactly as they occurred in court. We publish these case studies to give a genuine insight into the types of results we achieve and the range of sentences that may be imposed. Every case is different, and we can't guarantee the same result in your matter. We choose to share some cases because they are representative of typical results, and others because they stand out for exceptional outcomes.